Skip to content
NOWCAST WXII 12 News at 6 pm Sunday
Watch on Demand
Advertisement

What happens next following House Speaker Kevin McCarthy's ousting?

John Dinan, a political science professor at Wake Forest University weighs in this historic removal, and McCarthy's temporary replacement

What happens next following House Speaker Kevin McCarthy's ousting?

John Dinan, a political science professor at Wake Forest University weighs in this historic removal, and McCarthy's temporary replacement

TO OUR NATION’S CAPITAL NOW. A HISTORIC DAY IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES AS LAWMAKERS VOTE TO OUST THE HOUSE SPEAKER FOR THE FIRST TIME EVER, KEVIN MCCARTHY LOSING THE GAVEL IN A HISTORIC VOTE TODAY, 216 TO 210. NOW NEW QUESTIONS ABOUT WHERE EXACTLY REPUBLICANS GO FROM HERE. HERE’S KALYN NORWOOD TONIGHT FROM CAPITOL HILL. I WILL NOT RUN FOR SPEAKER AGAIN. KEVIN MCCARTHY SPEAKING HOURS AFTER THE HOUSE REMOVED HIM FROM HIS LEADERSHIP ROLE. HE SAYS DOING HIS JOB COST HIM HIS JOB, DOING THE RIGHT THING ISN’T ALWAYS EASY, BUT IT IS NECESSARY. I DON’T REGRET STANDING UP FOR CHOOSING GOVERNING OVER GRIEVANCE. HIS REMARKS CAPPING A CHAOTIC DAY IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES. THE OFFICE OF SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE OF THE UNITED STATES HOUSE OF REPRESENT ATIVES IS HEREBY DECLARED VACANT. HE HAD BATTLED LAWMAKERS FROM THE HARD LINE RIGHT FLANK FOR MONTHS, BUT THE LAST STRAW FOR THE CONSERVATIVE HARDLINERS. MCCARTHY’S WILLINGNESS TO WORK WITH DEMOCRATS TO AVOID A GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN CHAOS. IS SPEAKER MCCARTHY. CHAOS IS SOMEBODY WHO WE CANNOT TRUST WITH THEIR WORD. KINSTON THE MAJORITY OF THE GOP CAUCUS STUCK WITH MCCARTHY UNDER SPEAKER MCCARTHY’S LEADERSHIP. OUR HOUSE REPUBLICAN MAJORITY HAS ACTUALLY DEFIED ALL ODDS AND OVER PERFORMED EXPECTATIONS AGAIN AND AGAIN AND AGAIN. HOUSE DEMOCRATS SAID THEY WANT TO WORK WITH REPUBLICANS, BUT IT’S UP TO THE GOP TO DECIDE ON THEIR SPEAKER. WE ENCOURAGE MAGE OUR REPUBLICAN COLLEAGUES WHO CLAIM TO BE MORE TRADITIONAL RULE TO BREAK FROM THE EXTREMISTS. KEVIN MCCARTHY SELECTED NORTH CAROLINA REPRESENTATIVE PATRICK MCHENRY AS ACTING SPEAKER. HE’LL STAY IN THAT POSITION UNTIL A NEW SPEAKER IS SELECTED, THE CHAIR DECLARES THE HOUSE IN RECESS, SUBJECT TO THE CALL OF THE CHAIR. AND OUR COVERAGE CONTINUES WITH KARA PETERS. SHE JOINS US LIVE IN STUDIO. AND CARRIE, YOU SPOKE WITH A LOCAL EXPERT ABOUT THE NOW FORMER SPEAKER’S REMOVAL AND HIS TEMPORARY REPLACEMENT. WHAT DID YOU LEARN? KEN AND CHRISTINE, THIS IS UNCHARTERED TERRITORY FOLLOWING THIS HISTORIC SHOWDOWN TODAY. I SPOKE WITH WAKE FOREST UNIVERSITY, POLITICAL SCIENCE PROFESSOR JOHN DINON ON WHAT LED UP TO THIS MOMENT AND WHAT MUST BE DONE TO KEEP IT FROM HAPPENING AGAIN. AFTER LESS THAN NINE MONTHS, KEVIN MCCARTHY REMOVED AS HOUSE SPEAKER AN HISTORIC MOMENT THAT NOW LEAVES THE FUTURE IN QUESTION. THAT’S A BIG DEAL TO HAVE A SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE REMOVED IN THE MIDDLE OF THE TERM. PEOPLE HAVE USED THE TERM CHAOS TO DESCRIBE TODAY AND THE AFTERMATH OF TODAY. AND CHAOS IS AN APT DESCRIPTION, DYNAN SAYS THERE WERE SEVERAL FACTORS LEADING TO TENSIONS BETWEEN SEVERAL REPUBLICANS AND MCCARTHY, LIKE DISAGREEMENTS WITH SPENDING. BUT ALL OF THAT COMING TO A HEAD OVER THE WEEKEND FOLLOWING A NEAR GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN THAT WAS SAVED WITH THE HELP OF DEMOCRATS. THAT WAS A BRIDGE TOO FAR FOR SEVERAL OF THESE REPUBLICAN DISSENTERS. SO IN A WAY, SPEAKER MCCARTHY, BY WORKING WITH MEMBERS ACROSS THE AISLE TO ALLOW THE GOVERNMENT TO CONTINUE OPERATING AND NOT SHUT DOWN, BASICALLY SEALED HIS FATE. CONGRESSMAN PATRICK MCHENRY, WHO REPRESENTS NORTH CAROLINA’S 10TH DISTRICT, NOW STEPPING IN AS INTERIM SPEAKER, A CONFIDENTIAL DECISION THAT A HOUSE SPEAKER IS REQUIRED TO MAKE IF THEIR POSITION IS VACATED AT THE VERY BEGINNING OF THIS CONGRESS. KEVIN MCCARTHY CREATED THIS LIST. IT WAS A SECRET LIST. IT’S NOT A LIST THAT ANY OF US KNEW ABOUT TODAY. THEY AS SOON AS KEVIN MCCARTHY WAS VACATED FROM THE SPEAKER, THAT LIST BECAME PUBLIC. AND WHO WAS AT THE TOP OF THAT LIST WAS PATRICK MCHENRY. MOVING FORWARD, DYNAN SAYS THE DIFFICULTY WILL BE TRYING TO FIND A HOUSE SPEAKER THAT CAN APPEAL TO THE REPUBLICAN HOUSE MAJORITY, ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO PASSING LEGISLATION. IT SUGGESTS THAT IT’S GOING TO BE VERY DIFFICULT FOR REPUBLICANS GOING FORWARD TO REACH CONSENSUS. WE PROBABLY DON’T EXPECT MUCH IN THE WAY OF SIGNIFICANT LEGISLATION PASSING THIS CONGRESS. IF REPUBLICANS FIND IT SO DIFFICULT TO CHOOSE AND HOLD ON TO A SPEAKER, WILL IT BE PATRICK MCHENRY? WILL IT BE SOMEONE ELSE? THAT’S WHERE THE STORY TURNS. NOW. AND THIS ALL COMES WITH THE NEW STOPGAP SPENDING BILL IN PLACE, DENTON EXPLAINED. DURING THESE NEXT 45 DAYS, TIME WILL TELL WHAT HAPPENS NEXT FOR THE NEXT HOUSE SPEAKER. BUT ALSO IF WE COULD FACE ANOTHER POSSIBLE GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN.
Advertisement
What happens next following House Speaker Kevin McCarthy's ousting?

John Dinan, a political science professor at Wake Forest University weighs in this historic removal, and McCarthy's temporary replacement

After less than nine months, Kevin McCarthy is removed as House Speaker. An historic moment that now leaves the future in question."That's a big deal to have a speaker of the House removed in the middle of the term," said John Dinan, political science professor at Wake Forest University. "People have used the term 'chaos' to describe today and the aftermath of today, and chaos is an apt description."Dinan says there were several factors leading to tensions between several Republicans and McCarthy, like disagreements with spending. But all of that came to a head over the weekend; following a near government shutdown that was saved with the help of Democrats."That was a bridge too far for several of these Republican dissenters," Dinan said. "In a way, Speaker McCarthy, by working with members across the aisle to allow the government to continue operating and not shut down, basically sealed his fate."Congressman Patrick McHenry, who represents North Carolina's 10th district now stepping in as Interim Speaker. A confidential decision that a House Speaker is required to make if their position is vacated."At the beginning of this Congress, Kevin McCarthy created this list, it was a secret list, it's not a list that any of us knew about," Dinan said. "Today, as soon as Kevin McCarthy was vacated from the speaker, that list became public. And who was at the top of the list, was Patrick McHenry."Moving forward, Dinan says the difficulty will be trying to find a House Speaker that can appeal to the Republican House majority, especially when it comes to passing legislation."It suggests that is going to be very difficult for Republicans going forward to reach consensus," Dinan said. "We probably don't expect much in the way of significant legislation passing this Congress if Republicans find it so difficult to choose and hold onto a speaker."

After less than nine months, Kevin McCarthy is removed as House Speaker. An historic moment that now leaves the future in question.

"That's a big deal to have a speaker of the House removed in the middle of the term," said John Dinan, political science professor at Wake Forest University. "People have used the term 'chaos' to describe today and the aftermath of today, and chaos is an apt description."

Advertisement

Dinan says there were several factors leading to tensions between several Republicans and McCarthy, like disagreements with spending. But all of that came to a head over the weekend; following a near government shutdown that was saved with the help of Democrats.

"That was a bridge too far for several of these Republican dissenters," Dinan said. "In a way, Speaker McCarthy, by working with members across the aisle to allow the government to continue operating and not shut down, basically sealed his fate."

Congressman Patrick McHenry, who represents North Carolina's 10th district now stepping in as Interim Speaker. A confidential decision that a House Speaker is required to make if their position is vacated.

"At the beginning of this Congress, Kevin McCarthy created this list, it was a secret list, it's not a list that any of us knew about," Dinan said. "Today, as soon as Kevin McCarthy was vacated from the speaker, that list became public. And who was at the top of the list, was Patrick McHenry."

Moving forward, Dinan says the difficulty will be trying to find a House Speaker that can appeal to the Republican House majority, especially when it comes to passing legislation.

"It suggests that is going to be very difficult for Republicans going forward to reach consensus," Dinan said. "We probably don't expect much in the way of significant legislation passing this Congress if Republicans find it so difficult to choose and hold onto a speaker."